[{"NUM":29,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5605-3848-8","可外借数":3,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":52,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2011","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"钱学森的导师冯·卡门传","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"西安","索书号":"K835.156.16/F56","价格":0,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":795879,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"K835.156.16/F56","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"(美) 冯·卡门, 李·爱特生著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"西安交通大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"(美) 冯·卡门, 李·爱特生著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"钱学森的导师冯·卡门传","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1319419958000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":3,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":12,"调配员":"","修改人员":119,"出版者":"西安交通大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"f1b5151dcb40fd5118cde9b78525ce3a"},{"NUM":23,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5617-9221-6","可外借数":3,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":52,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2012","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"美国大学物理学科教学、科研史研究:1876-1950年","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"上海","索书号":"O4-4/Z62","价格":35,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1024868,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"O4-4/Z62","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"周志发著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"华东师范大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"周志发著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"美国大学物理学科教学、科研史研究18761950年","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1341301036000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":3,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":9,"调配员":"","修改人员":38,"出版者":"华东师范大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"24a09701eb67771ae19ebaff24901ca2"},{"NUM":20,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-301-21582-1","可外借数":3,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":112,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2012","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"纸","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"TS761/C47","价格":78,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1076857,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TS761/C47","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"陈燮君主编","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"北京大学出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"陈燮君主编","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"纸","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1367819288000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":3,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":12,"调配员":"","修改人员":119,"出版者":"北京大学出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"42ee86ca91772f17cc63599aebc4942d"},{"NUM":18,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"7-200-05668-5","可外借数":5,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":1,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":231296,"出版日期":"2004.12","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"中国国家地理 中 ","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"K92/J16/2","价格":0,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":69288,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"K92/J16/2","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"[纪江红主编]","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"北京出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"[纪江红主编]","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"中国国家地理 中","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1216608692000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"ZGGJDL Z ","丛书名":"","册数":5,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":31,"调配员":"","修改人员":1,"出版者":"北京出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"79dc1edbead15402494590a10e4c4ada"},{"NUM":17,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"7-5351-3628-1","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":1,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":234073,"出版日期":"2003.12","已外借数":1,"COVERPATH":"http://img7.doubanio.com/lpic/s1641093.jpg","题名2":"翻译论","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"武汉","索书号":"H059/X70-2","价格":0,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":73544,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"“尴尬”大都带有两种含义:它首先意味着一种无所适从的感觉;其次意味着一种进退两难的神态。前者是内隐的,只有当事者本人意识到;后者是外露的,可以被他人发现和留意。译者的尴尬也不外乎如此,它或隐或露地包含在译者的翻译实践和翻译理论中。 译者的尴尬完全是由译者的身份认同问题所引发的。当翻译界还主张译者是一个伺时原作者的仆人时,甚至信奉一仆(译者)二主(作者、读者)的观点时,译者的身份是明确的,因此也无尴尬可言。“尴尬”产生在对这样一个理论问题的思考和讨论中:作为译者,我们对原作者的思想究竟应当抱忠实的态度,还是应当持背叛的立场。 对这个问题的回答,早些年里是无须长思的,甚至可以说是不言而喻的。但近年来忠实论者受到的质疑甚多,风气一反以往。或许只是由于时代变了,因而突显的问题层面有所不同而已。但是,许多在我看来属于忠实论阵营的翻译实践者和翻译理论家,的确都或多或少在理论上认同并转向背叛论。这是我近年来常常感受到的一个事实,也是我在读完许钧的大作《翻译论》后又一次感受到的事实。[①] 许钧的《翻译论》相当系统周全,没有长年大量的翻译实践和翻译理论研究的积累,这样一部论著是拿不出来的。他的翻译论具体说来有翻译本质论、翻译过程论、翻译意义论、翻译因素论、翻译矛盾论、翻译主体论、翻译价值与批评论。但没有见到他提出过翻译类型论。我未做过专门研究,不知是否可以把所有翻译粗略地分为三类:1)技术类、2)文学类、3)思想类。 当然,这种分类是否还有遗漏,这个问题实际上并不重要。因为我在这里的主要意图是想说:如果以技术为主导的翻译与语言学的原理有关,例如与语际转换的规律有关,以文学为主导的翻译与文艺学的原理有关,例如与风格、神韵等等问题有关,那么以思想为主导的翻译就与解释学的原理有关,例如与理解和诠释的可能和限度有关。思想翻译必定包含着诠释的因素,当然首先也就包含理解的因素。而我关注的正是思想翻译。 无疑,思想翻译比其他翻译类型更多地涉及意义问题,首先涉及对作者原意的理解,然后涉及对这个原意的转述。我想翻译界的学者们大都不会否认这样一个基本事实的成立。再进一步说,如果与意义相对应的是思维,与转述或表述相对应的是语言,那么思想翻译在我看来首先也就是思维和语言的关系问题。 这个问题由来已久,古代西方的苏格拉底-柏拉图、亚里士多德讨论过这个问题,例如作为柏拉图所说的心灵与自身的对话;古代东方的佛教也讨论过这个问题,例如作为意业、语业、身业的关系;中国古代的思想家也在讨论,例如作为庄子所说的意与言的关系。到了近代,它更是成为一个关注的焦点,卢梭、赫尔德、洪堡、施莱尔马赫都把这个问题作为自己的思考重点。现代的维特根斯坦、胡塞尔、海德格尔也都仍然无法回避。更不用说当代的语言学和语言哲学、心理学和心智哲学,它在这些学科中依然占据着中心问题的位置。 关于思想翻译,前人已经说得很多,有许多可以拿来做参照的。我们这代人还能在此之外提供些什么新的东西呢?我对此把握不大。但我想,如果有,可能就是翻译理论界对译者身份的重新定位。忠实与叛逆,显然与这种对译者身份的重新界定有内在关联。 叛逆论之所以能够在翻译理论界占主导地位,很可能与当下的时代精神过多地偏好解释的权利有关。解释学中的读者中心论,在翻译论这里表现为译者中心论。很难说当代解释学的那几个原初倡导者们会乐于看到这个结果。 即便早个几十年,译者通常也还被要求以化身的方式融在译作之中。译者的主体意识虽然会随译者的自我意识的强弱程度不同而有或显或隐的宣露,但那是不自觉的,例如傅雷的译文风格并不是他本人刻意想要在译文中表露出来的。相反,在翻译一个与自己文笔风格不相容的作品时,译者还更有责任做出压抑自己的努力——当然,最好的方式是干脆不译那些与自己风格迴异的作品。倘若一个演员在演任何一个角色时都只想把他自己演出来,那么这个演员就很难说是出色的。翻译也是如此。W. R. 别林斯基便说过:“如果普希金想翻译歌德,那么我们会期待,在翻译中显现出来的不是他自己,而是歌德。”[②]在年初于中山大学召开的“翻译与解释”的研讨会上,我也曾直言不讳地对许钧说:“我买昆德拉的《不能承受的生命之轻》,并不是为了读许钧。” 这些要求应当是不言而喻的,甚至这里的重复都会显得多余。但另一方面又的确可以看到,在主张叛逆论的人中的确有一些像许钧这样的严肃学者,因而叛逆论的提出必定有它的理论基础。 首先需要指出的一点在于,如果有人主张忠实或叛逆,那么首先要弄清,忠实或叛逆是针对什么而言。在思想翻译中,例如在《圣经》翻译中,如果译者的任务像W. 本雅明所说的那样在于传达思想,那么语言表达上的叛逆就是可以容忍的。具体地说,以何种语言符号、表达方式、风格语气来传递同一个思想、转渡同一个意义,这是一个虽然不是无关紧要、但终究还是第二性的问题。与此相反,对思想或意义的叛逆","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"H059/X70-2","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"许钧著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"湖北教育出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"许钧著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"翻译论","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1216608720000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"FYL","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":3,"调配员":"","修改人员":1,"出版者":"湖北教育出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"cdf3778da5cd59ebafb78593eac4d687"},{"NUM":17,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5082-6295-6","可外借数":3,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":112,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2010","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"国际象棋入门","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"G891.1/X29","价格":0,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":721275,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"G891.1/X29","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"谢军,林峰编著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"金盾出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"谢军,林峰编著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"国际象棋入门","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1289869133000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"GJXQRM","丛书名":"","册数":3,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":30,"调配员":"","修改人员":119,"出版者":"金盾出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"b27ebf6db90bffabae7f134d1594b6b6"},{"NUM":16,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5100-4922-4","可外借数":3,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":112,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2013","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"章服之实:从沈从文先生晚年说起","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"TS941.742.2/W28","价格":49.8,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1084766,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"TS941.742.2/W28","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"王亚蓉编著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"世界图书出版公司北京公司","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"王亚蓉编著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"章服之实从沈从文先生晚年说起","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1369120705000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":3,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":9,"调配员":"","修改人员":38,"出版者":"世界图书出版公司北京公司","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"fc4667080a74a32dc9e685b165e50a74"},{"NUM":14,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"978-7-5426-3784-0","可外借数":3,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":112,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"chi","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":0,"出版日期":"2012","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"制陶术的生成","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"上海","索书号":"K866.3/Y56","价格":76,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":1048018,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"K866.3/Y56","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"尧波著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"三联书店","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"尧波著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"制陶术的生成","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1351577322000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"","丛书名":"","册数":3,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":8,"调配员":"","修改人员":119,"出版者":"三联书店","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"5a55b6fca5e9a33ab7b329426a11b22b"},{"NUM":14,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"7-119-04257-2","可外借数":2,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":1,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":329319,"出版日期":"2006","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"江苏:穿行水乡","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"K925.3/S31","价格":0,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":140649,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"K925.3/S31","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"外文出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"江苏穿行水乡","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1216609196000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"JS:CXSX","丛书名":"","册数":2,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":18,"调配员":"","修改人员":1,"出版者":"外文出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"7b28ecc624df195c6f45e77ef528558e"},{"NUM":14,"bookMap":{"种次F":"","标准编码":"7-111-16510-1","可外借数":5,"上月外借册数":0,"去年外借册数":0,"封面":"","采编审核":0,"分类字符数据":"","全文服务器ID":0,"操作员":1,"索书号2":"","种次数据":"","内容介绍1":"","语种":"","本月外借册数":0,"排架号":"","库键码":1,"ILAS记录号":293154,"出版日期":"2005","已外借数":0,"COVERPATH":"","题名2":"老板要你在大学里学的10件事","采编审核员":"","分类号":"","出版地":"北京","索书号":"B848.4/K28.2","价格":0,"索书号5":"","索书号6":"","种次字母":"","索书号3":"","责任者一":"","索书号4":"","索书号9":"","翻阅次数":0,"主键码":118674,"索书号7":"","索书号8":"","SUMMARYS":"","今年外借册数":0,"编目审核员":"","调配时间":"","索书号A":"B848.4/K28.2","责任者三":"","责任者二":"","分类":"","编目审核":0,"预约数":0,"编目审核日期":"","封面地址":"","内容介绍":"","责任者四":"","文献类型":0,"图象页数":0,"责任者":"(美) 比尔·科普林著","版次":"","下载":0,"种次字符数据":"","分类数据":"","出版者2":"机械工业出版社","MARC类型":"","封面服务器ID":0,"首馆键码":1,"索书号15":"","采编审核日期":"","索书号14":"","索书号13":"","索书号12":"","索书号11":"","责任者2":"(美) 比尔·科普林著","索书号10":"","全文地址":"","题名":"老板要你在大学里学的10件事","翻译题名":"","处理日期":1216609053000,"分类字母":"","题名缩写":"LBYNZDXLXD10JS","丛书名":"","册数":5,"索书号16":"","累计外借册数":111,"调配员":"","修改人员":1,"出版者":"机械工业出版社","创建时间":"","卷标":"","种次":"","下载服务器ID":0,"下载地址":""},"ID":"4dda60f11d61d8471b65bfbbe127b3d1"}]